Photo: Pexels
Every new majority faces the same question: who decides what it is for? For Rep. Ayanna Pressley of Massachusetts, the answer should be bold. In posts after the midterms, she urged Democrats to use their power to pass Medicare for All, enact the EACH Act to restore abortion coverage in public insurance, repeal the Hyde Amendment, pursue reparations and abolish Immigration and Customs Enforcement.
“Democrats, don’t just talk about health care justice, pass Medicare for All,” she wrote, according to Political.org.
A Speaker petition
Pressley’s message found an audience. A Change.org petition calling for her to become Speaker of the House had gathered more than 18,000 signatures by November 11, Common Dreams reported. Pressley has not signaled any challenge to Democratic leader Hakeem Jeffries, who is expected to become Speaker in January. But she struck a pointed tone, writing that “it’s not enough to be the adults in the room.”
A tally by Drop Site found 49 House Democrats publicly pledged to Jeffries, 23 uncommitted and none opposed. The Speaker needs a majority of the full House, typically 218 votes, in the floor election.
The tension in the caucus
The new Democratic majority includes members elected in deep-blue districts who campaigned on transformative change, and members who won Republican-leaning seats by promising to fix practical problems like prices and health costs. Medicare for All and abolishing ICE are popular with the first group and politically dangerous for the second.
That tension is not new. It shaped the Democratic majorities of 2019 and 2021 as well. But this time, Democrats control both chambers without the presidency, meaning their legislation is likely to be vetoed regardless. Some progressives argue that makes it the perfect moment to pass maximal bills as statements of values. Moderates argue that symbolic votes on controversial ideas give Republicans campaign material for 2028.
Fox News’ framing
Conservative outlets have seized on Pressley’s posts as evidence that Democrats plan to govern from the left. That framing is predictable, but it also signals how Republicans intend to run against the new majority.
Our take
Pressley is right that winning majorities is pointless if they do not change people’s lives. But leadership in a divided government is about choosing which fights produce results. The most persuasive progressive agenda for the next two years may be one focused on achievable wins, such as lowering drug prices, protecting health coverage and oversight of immigration enforcement abuses, while building public support for bigger ideas over time. The Speaker petition is unlikely to go anywhere, but it is a useful signal to Jeffries: a significant part of the party’s base wants a fighter, not a manager. He will need to show both qualities.
Sources: Political.org; Common Dreams; Drop Site tally as reported by Common Dreams.