Photo: Pexels
The artificial intelligence boom needs electricity, water and land, and the land it needs is not empty. In Bessemer, Alabama, a tiny fish described by scientists only about two years ago has become an unlikely test case for how the country balances data center growth with endangered species protection.
The darter
The Birmingham darter is roughly two inches long and survives in just six known populations, according to Inside Climate News. One of those populations lies in the path of Project Marvel, a 4.5-million-square-foot, 1,200-megawatt data center under construction on 700 acres in Bessemer. Data center operator QTS bought the project for $432 million in June, according to local reports, and crews are clearing land.
The legal fight
Nearly a year ago, the Alabama Rivers Alliance, the Center for Biological Diversity and Black Warrior Riverkeeper petitioned the US Fish and Wildlife Service to consider listing the darter under the Endangered Species Act. Under the law, the agency is supposed to make an initial finding within 90 days. On Thursday, November 12, the groups sent a notice of intent to sue, saying the agency had missed that deadline. They will file suit if the agency does not respond within 60 days.
Charles Miller of the Alabama Rivers Alliance said the darter is “endangered in fact, if not by law.” Neither the Fish and Wildlife Service nor QTS responded to requests for comment.
A wider pattern
Endangered species listings have slowed under the current administration, and critics say decisions are being delayed for species whose protection might complicate development. Supporters of faster development argue that the Endangered Species Act is often used to block economically important projects and that small populations of newly described species should not halt major investments.
The data center question adds a new dimension. Across the United States, facilities for AI and cloud computing are being built at enormous scale. A study reported this week found that the 400 largest US data centers emit as much heat-trapping gas annually as Denmark. Communities are also asking about water use, noise and power prices.
Our take
The Endangered Species Act was designed for exactly this kind of situation: a species with very few populations facing a specific, identifiable threat. Listing does not automatically stop a project; it requires developers and agencies to find ways to avoid driving a species to extinction. Ignoring a legal deadline helps no one, including the developer, which now faces litigation risk. The responsible path is for the agency to make its decision on the science and for the company to explore design changes that protect the stream. A digital future that wipes out species that were only just discovered is a poor trade.
Sources: Inside Climate News; Center for Biological Diversity; Daily Climate/AP headline on data center emissions.