Photo: Pexels
Singapore has bet much of its energy future on its neighbors. The city-state, short of land for solar farms and dependent on imported natural gas, has signed deals to import low-carbon electricity from around the region. Its regulator gave conditional approval for 3.4 gigawatts of power from Indonesia alone. Now Jakarta has slammed on the brakes.
Indonesia’s position
On November 2, Indonesian Energy Minister Bahlil Lahadalia said Indonesia is holding out for a better price. “If the price isn’t right, then we will prioritize domestic needs,” he said, according to Mongabay. Indonesia has said it will not allow the planned export projects to proceed for now.
The decision follows other moves to prioritize domestic energy, including cuts to gas exports to Singapore, which Thai Prime Minister Anutin Charnvirakul cited this month as an example of how energy nationalism is reshaping the region.
Investors caught in the middle
The freeze has left companies stranded. Equator Renewables Asia received final approval in May for a 50-kilometer undersea cable across the Singapore Strait. Its CEO, Frank Phuan, says the project is now on hold. Investors are hoping for diplomatic help to restart the plans, which together represent tens of billions of dollars in potential investment.
Singapore’s demand is rising fast. Peak electricity demand could increase by as much as half by 2031, driven partly by data centers and electric vehicles.
The haze connection
The energy dispute has become entangled with an old irritant: transboundary haze from Indonesian fires. In late October, Singapore’s National Environment Agency served notices on 10 companies over possible fires on concessions in Indonesia. Singapore’s foreign minister then visited President Prabowo Subianto. Indonesian officials have historically bristled at what they see as Singapore lecturing them on fires while benefiting from Indonesian resources.
Bigger regional picture
The ASEAN Power Grid, a long-planned network linking the region’s electricity systems, depends on countries trusting that cross-border power deals will be honored. If the region’s largest economy treats exports as a bargaining chip, other projects may also stall.
Our take
Indonesia has every right to seek a fair price and to protect domestic supply, especially after a year of energy shocks. But using approved projects as leverage carries costs. It raises risk premiums for every investor in the region and undermines the vision of an integrated ASEAN grid that would benefit Indonesia too. The best outcome would be a transparent pricing framework that both sides can defend at home, negotiated separately from the haze dispute. Mixing the two issues risks a stalemate in which neither clean power nor clean air arrives.
Sources: Mongabay; Nation Thailand.