Photo: Pexels
Menhaden are not glamorous fish. They are small, oily and rarely eaten by people. But they sit at the base of the Atlantic food web, feeding striped bass, whales, dolphins and seabirds, and they are ground up in vast quantities for fish meal and oil. This month, the regulators who manage them decided to take fewer.
The decision
At its annual meeting in Newport, Rhode Island, from November 9 to 12, the Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission’s menhaden board cut the coastwide catch limit by about 9% for 2027 and another 9% for 2028, Inside Climate News reports. The total allowable catch will fall from 186,840 metric tons in 2026 to 170,000 in 2027 and 155,000 in 2028.
The cap on the so-called reduction fishery inside the Chesapeake Bay, where most industrial menhaden fishing takes place, will drop 27% in 2027 and 34% by 2028, to 37,123 and 33,847 metric tons respectively. Coastwide limits take effect January 1, 2027, while the Bay cap begins May 1.
Not enough, say scientists
The cuts come with a caveat. The commission’s own technical committee found that even a 39% reduction would give only a 50% chance of meeting its ecological target, the level of menhaden needed to support predators. The adopted limits will very likely miss that target. The board also rejected a proposal to split quotas into seasonal periods, which advocates said would protect fish during the summer months when predators need them most.
Allison Colden of the Chesapeake Bay Foundation called the Bay cut “a significant win” but warned that it still leaves the door open to heavy summer catches.
The ospreys’ warning
The urgency is visible in the sky. Survey data show 81% of monitored osprey nesting pairs in the Bay’s saltier waters failed to raise a single chick in 2026. Ospreys depend heavily on menhaden to feed their young, and scientists have pointed to food shortages as a likely factor in the breeding failures.
Industry concerns
The reduction fishery, centered in Virginia, supports jobs in coastal communities and supplies fish meal for aquaculture and fish oil for supplements. Industry representatives have argued that menhaden stocks are healthy overall and that the cuts are unnecessary.
Our take
Fisheries management often fails by asking how many fish can be taken rather than how many must be left. The menhaden decision is a step toward the second question, which is the right direction. But the commission’s own scientists say the step is too short. Ecosystem-based management only works if regulators follow their models even when results are inconvenient. The ospreys of the Chesapeake are telling a clear story. Waiting for definitive proof before acting may mean losing a generation of birds and the fish that feed them.
Sources: Inside Climate News; Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission.