Photo: Pexels
The Trump administration’s effort to end the war in Ukraine is back in motion. US envoy Steve Witkoff announced in early November that the United States would bring Ukrainian and Russian delegations together in Abu Dhabi on November 10 and 11, listing the agenda as “post-war security agreements, de-escalation, humanitarian measures, and ending the war,” according to Reuters.
What Abu Dhabi produced
The AP reported that the Abu Dhabi session was the first direct talks between Ukraine and Russia in nine months. It produced no major breakthrough, apart from agreement on a planned large prisoner exchange, with the number not yet announced.
On to Moscow, then Dublin
On Thursday, November 12, Witkoff and Jared Kushner, the lead US negotiators, met Russian President Vladimir Putin at the Kremlin for about two hours. They then flew to Dublin to meet Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy for more than an hour. Putin’s aide Yuri Ushakov described the Kremlin talks as “substantive, constructive, frank and useful.”
Putin also restated a key red line: the presence of European troops in Ukraine after a ceasefire would be “absolutely unacceptable,” according to the AP. Several European governments have discussed sending forces to help guarantee any settlement, and Kyiv sees such guarantees as essential to prevent a future Russian attack.
The core obstacles
Earlier rounds of US-led diplomacy stumbled on the same questions. Russia has demanded Ukrainian territory, particularly in the eastern Donbas region, which Kyiv refuses to surrender. Ukraine wants binding security guarantees. Europe wants a role in shaping the outcome. Washington wants a deal it can present as a diplomatic win.
Domestic politics
The talks resume days after Republicans lost control of Congress. Democrats in the new majority are likely to press for continued support to Ukraine and for oversight of any agreement involving territorial concessions or sanctions relief for Russia. That could strengthen Kyiv’s hand in insisting on guarantees, or complicate the administration’s room to maneuver.
Our take
Any process that gets Ukrainian and Russian negotiators into the same room, and produces a prisoner exchange, is worth something. Families on both sides will welcome it. But the description of talks as constructive has been used many times before without changing facts on the ground. The real test is whether either side shifts its position on territory and security guarantees. Until Moscow accepts some form of credible protection for Ukraine after a ceasefire, and Kyiv accepts some painful compromise, peace will remain a schedule of meetings rather than a settlement. Washington’s role should be to make sure any deal is durable, not merely fast.
Sources: Reuters via Al-Monitor; AP via CP24; Kyiv Independent.