Photo: Pexels
Every climate summit eventually reaches the same fault line: what to say about the fuels that cause most of the problem. At COP31 in Antalya, that fault line appeared on the first day.
As the summit opened on November 9, the Arab Group of negotiators, including Saudi Arabia, Iraq and the United Arab Emirates, opposed any reference in a COP31 decision to the roadmaps produced by last year’s Brazilian presidency, according to reporting by Greek daily To Vima citing the Earth Negotiations Bulletin. The European Union took the opposite position, backing the roadmaps along with faster electrification and cuts to methane emissions.
What Brazil proposed
Brazil’s roadmap, released on November 3, is a 182-page voluntary document that was never negotiated among governments. It proposes a coordinated push through 2033, which it calls a “TAFF Mutirão,” using a Brazilian word for collective effort, along with a framework for assessing how dependent each country is on fossil fuels. A companion roadmap covers halting deforestation by 2030, and a third document sets out a path to scale climate finance to at least $1.3 trillion a year by 2035.
Reactions from campaigners were mixed. Greenpeace Brazil said the roadmap stops short of setting clear phase-out targets. 350.org described it as a critical handbook for ending the fossil fuel era.
Phase-out or phase-down
Gulf producers have long preferred “phase-down” language, which implies reducing use without ending it. But the expansion problem is not limited to the Gulf. Analysis cited by Eco-Business identified the United States, Canada, Australia and Norway as major drivers of oil and gas growth, with their combined output up nearly 40% between 2015 and 2024. The host country, Türkiye, is also pursuing new coal projects.
A parallel track
Some countries are no longer waiting for consensus. Tuvalu and Ireland are set to co-host the next fossil fuel transition conference next year, part of a coalition-of-the-willing approach that bypasses the unanimity rule of UN talks.
Our take
The fight over a single reference to a voluntary document shows how fragile the Dubai consensus of 2023 really was. Governments agreed then to transition away from fossil fuels, but they never agreed on how fast, by whom or with what money. Brazil’s roadmap tries to answer those questions, which is precisely why producers want it kept out of the official record. If COP31 cannot even mention the plan, the most important climate work of the next decade may happen in smaller coalitions outside the UN process. That might be faster, but it would leave the biggest producers outside the tent.
Sources: To Vima; Eco-Business; Common Dreams; Climate Home News.