Photo: Pexels
Justice Samuel Alito’s warning that Congress can “turn off the lights” at the Supreme Court drew headlines this month. Less noticed is the more practical funding question underneath it: how to protect justices and judges in what court officials describe as a heightened threat environment.
The rare trip to Capitol Hill
On July 14, Justices Elena Kagan and Amy Coney Barrett made a rare appearance before congressional appropriators to request more money, focused heavily on security. Court decisions were off-limits, but the hearing revealed how personal the threats have become.
Barrett said that many pizzas and packages had been sent to justices’ homes under the name “Daniel Anderl,” according to Talking Points Memo. Daniel Anderl was the son of federal Judge Esther Salas; he was killed in 2020 by a gunman who came to the family’s home. Using his name on deliveries is widely seen as an intimidation tactic, signaling that the sender knows where justices live. Barrett also referred to a swatting incident at her home in late May.
Rhetoric and risk
During the hearing, Sen. Jack Reed of Rhode Island read aloud insults President Trump had directed at justices. Kagan said such statements “are really unhelpful.” Kagan also said she still supports an enforcement mechanism for the Court’s ethics code, while Barrett was more hesitant, citing difficulty in deciding who would adjudicate complaints.
Justices speaking out
The budget debate comes as justices have become more publicly vocal. Alito, speaking at the Federalist Society on November 12, warned against congressional interference and criticized some lower-court judges. Justice Clarence Thomas gave a widely shared speech earlier this year warning that modern progressivism threatens the country’s founding principles. These public interventions make the Court’s relationship with the new Democratic majority more delicate.
What Congress may do
Security funding has historically enjoyed bipartisan support, and few lawmakers want to be seen as leaving judges unprotected. The likelier fights involve ethics: Democrats may tie funding discussions to transparency on gifts, travel and recusals. Defunding the Court, as Alito warned, is not on the table in any serious proposal.
Our take
Protecting judges from violence should be one of the least controversial items in any budget. Judges who fear for their families cannot rule freely, and a justice system under intimidation serves no one, whatever their politics. Congress should fully fund security for the Supreme Court and lower courts, and political leaders of all parties should stop rhetoric that targets judges personally. Ethics reform is a legitimate debate, but it should be pursued on its own merits, not by holding security funding hostage. On this one, both sides should give the Court what it needs.
Sources: Talking Points Memo; The National News Desk; Fox News; RedState.