Photo: Pexels
Electric vehicles are supposed to be a climate solution. The batteries that power many of them depend on nickel, and Indonesia, which could supply up to 74% of the world’s nickel by 2040, is where the solution meets one of its sharpest contradictions.
The study
A study published in Nature Ecology & Evolution, led by Jayden Hyman of the University of Queensland, finds that 44% to 49% of projected nickel demand between 2025 and 2050 could come from mines located in the top 10% of land areas for biodiversity and carbon storage, Mongabay reports. Excluding those areas from mining could leave a shortfall of up to 18% of 2050 demand under the International Energy Agency’s announced pledges scenario.
“This is a call to action to work together,” Hyman said.
Overlap on the ground
A separate analysis by the Indonesian group AEER found that 28 of 206 Key Biodiversity Areas in Sulawesi and Maluku overlap with 109 nickel concessions. These islands host species found nowhere else, including endemic macaques, anoa and birds.
Communities feel the impact directly. On Kabaena Island, a Mongabay investigation documented forest loss, coastal sedimentation and fishers reporting large income declines. In Raja Ampat, a UNESCO biosphere reserve and one of the world’s richest marine areas, Greenpeace reports that several companies still pursue nickel projects despite government statements that permits were revoked.
Not all for batteries
There is an important nuance. A 2026 analysis by the Centre for Research on Energy and Clean Air estimated that about 83% of Indonesia’s 2025 nickel production went into stainless steel rather than batteries. That means the environmental cost of nickel mining cannot be blamed solely on electric vehicles, and battery makers have leverage to demand cleaner supply chains.
What could help
Researchers point to several options: no-go zones for mining in high-biodiversity areas, better recycling to reduce demand for new metal, battery chemistries that use less nickel, and stronger requirements on smelters, many of which still run on coal power. Buyers in Europe, the United States and East Asia can also use procurement standards to favor responsible producers.
Our take
The energy transition will require mining. Pretending otherwise helps no one. But it matters where and how that mining happens. Indonesia’s nickel boom has brought investment and jobs, yet it is also clearing forests, polluting coasts and burning coal to process ore. If the world’s clean energy supply chain is built on destroyed ecosystems, it will be neither clean nor just. Mapping no-go zones now, before the next wave of concessions, is far cheaper than trying to restore islands after the forests are gone.
Sources: Mongabay; Nature Ecology & Evolution; AEER; CREA; Eco-Business.